What Is a Reporter?
- Home
- Raportör Nedir
Criminal • IT • Legal Reporter and the “Private Hospital Model” in Judicial Proceedings
Today, the course of a legal dispute or criminal case is determined not only by physical evidence and witness statements, but also by digital evidence such as cell phones, computers, HTS records, cell tower data, social media communications, and other digital evidence that can contribute to resolving the case. The primary function of forensic computing is to collect, examine, and report on digital materials in a manner that preserves the integrity of the evidence and ensures it is admissible in court.
As part of the “Next-Generation Forensic Solutions” offered by DNA Forensic and Digital Forensics, the aim is to evaluate incidents and evidence holistically, establish a connection between cause and effect, and, through the process of examination, evaluation, and analysis, contribute to the discovery of the material truth by providing a technical report and presenting the defense based on that report.
It All Starts with People; Technology Is Just a Detail
An Assessment from a Forensic Computing Perspective
What Is a Reporter?
The Concept of the Rapporteur and the New Generation of Expertise
The term “rapporteur” refers to experts who provide opinions to decision-makers by examining cases from technical and legal perspectives, particularly within the higher courts. The relevant legislation clearly emphasizes the critical roles of rapporteurs in conducting the initial and substantive review of cases, preparing reports, and drafting decisions.
In the field of DNA Forensics and Digital Forensics, the concept of a “reporting expert” refers to a multidisciplinary approach that establishes a strategic link between the incident, evidence, technical analysis, and legal defense to contribute to the discovery of the material truth in an investigation or prosecution. Within this comprehensive approach, a robust defense strategy will be built based on the technical report prepared following the examination of digital evidence.
Criminal • Cybercrime • Legal Reporter: What Do They Do?
In light of this information, a reporter’s role is not so much to locate target data as it is to evaluate the files and data found according to the 5W1H framework. This multifaceted expertise is based on three key pillars:
Criminal Approach:
It establishes a strong logical connection between the incident and the evidence. It evaluates the relevance of the digital evidence purported to be related to the incident.
IT Expertise:
Procedures involving digital materials alleged to have been directly used in the incident are conducted in accordance with the Chain of Custody protocols outlined in the ISO 27037 standards, thereby ensuring that the evidence cannot be tampered with. The technical analyses to be submitted to judicial authorities and the reports to be prepared are drafted at this stage by individuals who have received and provided international-level training.
Legal Perspective:
Based on the findings in the report prepared under the provisions of Article 67 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Expert Opinion) and Article 293 of the Civil Procedure Code (Scientific Opinion) following the examination of digital evidence, we determine how these findings can be transformed into a strategic advantage within the case file. We ensure that the technically focused work prepared based on this report is transformed into a strong legal defense capable of convincing the court. These reports will possess the same legal weight as official expert reports.
The “Private Hospital Model” in Legal Proceedings
What sets DNA Forensic and Digital Forensics apart is its use of the Private Hospital Model, which is based on a “diagnosis and treatment process” approach for every case. This model consists of four critical stages:
Analysis (Evidence Collection and Preliminary Analysis):
In a hospital, the first step in the treatment process is diagnostic testing; in digital forensics, it is the data collection process. This involves identifying and collecting digital materials (such as phones, drives, and log files) at the scene of the incident, and securing the data by creating exact copies without altering the originals. In emergency situations, evidence collection under Live Forensic procedures is also carried out during this phase.
Investigation (Evidence Collection, Preservation, and Chronology):
At this stage, we will establish the necessary processes and create a timeline to identify the target files or data that will contribute to resolving the incident. The duration of this process will vary depending on the volume of evidence and the systems to be used.
Diagnosis (Technical Validation and Correlation):
Following the Process phase, the analysis and interpretation of files or data (HTS, messages, location data) relevant to the resolution of the incident will be conducted during this phase. If no files or data relevant to the resolution of the incident are identified, or if anti-forensic measures are involved, potential scenarios related to this situation will also be outlined during this phase.
Treatment (Technical Report and Defense):
The process of documenting the files or data identified as a result of the above activities in a manner that is understandable to everyone constitutes the preparation of a technical report, which can be considered part of the treatment process. The technical report is subject to review, as it is intended to provide relevant courts with information and guidance on the matter. Reports are prepared to be brief, concise, and clear—focusing on contributing to the resolution of the case rather than on complex technical explanations—and are written in a manner that is understandable to everyone.
The Silent Testimony of Digital Evidence:
Digital evidence or data serves as a key witness in these cases. Therefore, the reports we prepare during the legal process are intended to prevent wrongful accusations resulting from the misinterpretation of files or data, and to prevent irreparable harm.
Why Is an Expert Reporter Needed?
In DNA forensic and digital forensics, misidentification can lead to incorrect conclusions. A broken chain of evidence or weak correlations can obscure the material truth. DNA forensic and digital forensics ensures quality through internal control protocols by guaranteeing that every technical report undergoes a review and approval process by at least three experts before it is submitted.
Peer Review and the Development of a Counterargument
In the legal field, it is not enough to simply present your own arguments; it is also critical to identify gaps in the technical claims presented by the opposing party. DNA Forensic and Digital Forensics examines flawed or incomplete technical reports submitted to the case file and prepares a “Counter-Expert Opinion” that strengthens the defense’s position, thereby preventing the distortion of the factual truth.
Conclusion
The answer to the question “What is a forensic analyst?” takes on a professional dimension with the Private Hospital Model offered by DNA Forensic and Digital Forensics. The Forensic • Digital • Legal Analyst is the most reliable partner, bridging the gap between the incident, the evidence, and the defense.
The reports we prepare are not merely text-based. Complex HTS traffic, log records, and location data are visualized through infographic maps and interactive timelines that the court can understand at a glance.
It is important to remember that digital traces are ephemeral; over time, data can be overwritten or permanently deleted. In DNA Forensics and Computer Forensics, adhering to the “Golden Hours” principle, it is vital to seek professional assistance without delay to prevent the destruction of evidence.
Take Action: If your case requires digital evidence, HTS records, mobile device forensics, or an expert opinion, contact DNA Criminal and Forensic IT Consulting to support your defense with a robust report.
Using a DNA Forensic and Digital Forensics approach:
A technical report is finalized only after undergoing a review and approval process by at least three experts prior to delivery.
For technical support, forensic reporting, and professional defense;
0552 676 11 00 – 
dna@kriminalbilisim.com